Gold And Silver – Opposing Forces Very Under-Rated. Ode On A [Un]Grecian Chart

Sunday  30 December 2012

It is impossible not to read some source, informed or otherwise, touting the
“fact” that the price of gold and silver will be  [insert whatever amount you
wish, here], “in the coming months”, or safer, “in the next year or two,” etc.
Yet, the market does not echo those almost universally held sentiments.

Why not?

Because that is exactly what they are, sentiments.  When it comes to
sentiments or opinions, regardless of how close to source or how well
reasoned, the market does not care.  One of the better “resolutions”
one can make going into 2013 and beyond is to follow the market’s
lead, stop trying to lead it, waiting for it to catch up to your
trading acumen.

But what about the shortages in silver production v demand?  What about
the overly re-re-hypothecated gold leases from central banks that cannot
possibly cover actual demands for gold?  What about the possibility that
all of Germany’s [and other countries?] gold is gone and so much of it is
being transferred to the East?  What about [insert whatever issue you wish
discussed, here]?

Yes, well what about it!  That information is and has been known for quite
some time, so it is already “priced into the market.”  It does not matter how
well-informed your source[s] is.  It does not matter how accurate the
figures are for available supply  v demand.  The market is all knowing, and
it is ahead of you, and it is responding to forces about which you are not
aware, hidden deals, as an example.

It  does not matter how much gold there is, or isn’t.  It does not matter where
the gold is, or isn’t, the market is telling you what you all you need to know.

Everything finds its way into the market, and if you would just ignore all
else and follow the ultimate known fact, that being the current price of
anything, then you have the answer right in front of you.  The problem is,
too many cannot reconcile the current price of gold and silver relative to
their expectations.  [From the buy side.]

John Keats would have made an excellent technical analyst, for he excelled
at drawing out the paradoxical nature of things, leaving us with a few of his
most famous lines that apply to the above:

‘Beauty is Truth, Truth Beauty’ — that is all
Ye know of earth, and all ye need to know.
From ‘Ode On A Grecian Urn’

This is how we see charts.  Everything you need to know is contained
within them because they are based on truth.  What truth?  The ultimate
decisions to buy or sell made by the collective forces of the marketplace.
Anything else that does not get translated directly in the market is simply
an opinion, of no factual value because the market only recognizes actual

That is the truth and the beauty of the markets.  They provide you factual
commitments, unadorned by uncommitted interpretive opinions.  That is
all ye need to know on earth.  Learn to listen to what the market is saying,
and not what others are saying about the market.

This is not to say that markets cannot be manipulated and factors grossly
distorted, for even if they are, those manipulation and distortions are what
is reflected in current prices, like it or not.

Most who speculate in the markets, to the extent they rely upon charts,
look at  daily or intra day time frames.  Smart money, what we call the
“controlling forces” of a market, use higher time frames, for they are
not concerned with day-to-day activity.  Their positions and influence
necessitate that they move over a more extended period of time, and
one can get a greater sense of their intent from the higher time frames.

When we talk about collective forces of the marketplace, it includes
the most well-informed insiders, central bankers, the largest dealers,
with availability to information and research outsiders may never
know or learn about, until after the fact, all the way down to investors,
fundamentalists, speculators, even the ephemeral day-traders.  What
they all have in common is that they are the market, once they make
a decision to execute a buy/sell  that influences and determines the price
at any given point in time.  Those executed decisions, regardless of how
well or ill-informed,  become market facts that comprise  fluctuations,
and they show up as the high, low, and close on a chart for any chosen
time frame.

Despite the relentless calls for gold and silver “taking off,” which they
have not, of late, the elephants in the room, governments, central bankers
and major brokers, plus exchanges, have been vastly under-rated in their
ability to keep the prices of gold and silver suppressed as much as they have.
They are not about to throw in the towel and give up their Wizard of Oz
controls.  Ultimately, they are doomed to fail, but when does “ultimately”
kick in, and to what degree of damage before it does, remains unknown?

One thing you should know about the opposition, in whatever form it is
in, ultimately:  It will not stop.  It will not quit.  It will destroy everything
that gets into its way in order to suit its needs.

The charts have been saying as much.  The annual and quarterly charts had
to be scanned because most services do not provide any beyond the monthly
time frame.  The comments on the charts may be hard to read, so we will put
them in italics to make it easier.

If gold and silver are going to go to such high price levels, why are charts
saying the opposite?  This end of year’s gold closing, actually Monday, is about
mid-range the bar, a draw between the forces of supply and demand, but the
range was the smallest in several years.  Neither buyers nor sellers were able
to extend the range further in either direction.

Chart comments:

This year’s close is higher, but the entire range is within last year’s.  The
bar is one of the smallest annual ranges in five years, and the close is just
under the half-bar area.  The conclusion would be neutral to just a touch
negative.  The quarterly chart may reveal more.

GCA A 30 Dec 12

The arrow in the chart points to the smallest range in Qtr 2, 2012.  It was an
attempt to go lower that failed.  The fact, and keep in mind the focus is on the
indisputable facts contained in the charts, that price did not go lower speaks
to strong support at that level.

Another observable fact is how the last 5 quarterly bars have been overlapping.
Anytime you see bars overlapping, it show a struggle between buyers and sellers
trying to exert control.  The poor end of the year close for gold says buyers have
not been keeping an upper hand, and sellers are maintaining relentless pressure.

Chart comments:

Comments under the trading range cover expectations going into 2013.  The one
positive Qtr was 2nd, 2012, when price tried to go lower but held, and the close
was mid-range the bar, a win for buyers with price higher ever since.

Last 5 Qtrs are within range of 3rd Qtr 2011, and the last 4 Qtrs within 4th Q 2011.

Low-end close for 2012 says sellers in control.  Expect more price range activity
going into 2013+.

Pie-in-the-sky prices are not in the picture, for now.  A retest of 1520+ area possible.

GCA Q 30 Dec 12


Back to our normal chart.  If we view the rally in August as a breakout from a
right triangle pattern, it is taking now 3 months to correct a 2 month rally, and
the bars correcting are smaller, telling us there is no downward ease of movement.
This suggests sellers are meeting more resistance, but still prevailing.

2013 will be an interesting year, and its start could be signaling more of what we
have seen for the past 15 months.  While accumulation of the physical metal is
strongly recommended, trading in the paper futures will have to be much more
select, buying breaks, not breakouts.

GCA M 30 Dec 12

There is no question that silver remains relatively weaker to gold, as the charts clearly
show.  Some think silver may outperform gold, moving forward, and it has, on occasion.
That is an opinion that may or may not hold true.  Buying and personally holding the
physical is strongly recommended, as was stated for gold.  For now, silver has a very
large supply factor hanging over future progress, based upon the closes of 2011 and 2012.

Chart comments:

2011 silver close was bottom-end on very high volume.  This single bar shouts out
sellers were totally in control, and everything above the close is where buyers have
to overcome seller’s efforts, and that is a pretty large area to regain.

In 2012, the range attempt to go higher was small, and another low end close shows
how buyers are failing to overcome sellers, a problem for longs.

SIA A 30 Dec 12

The more detailed Qtrly chart has one positive aspect:  26.20+ area held like a rock.
We could see yet another test and possible new low.  That is not a prediction but a
point of view not to be dismissed for the year ahead.  As with gold, the overlapping of
bars shows the struggle between the forces of sellers and buyers, the edge with sellers.

Chart comments:

The Qtrly chart is more of a mixed message.  There is obviously strong support at the
26 area, and bullish spacing remains a positive.
[Bullish spacing is where the current
swing low is above the last swing high, indicating buyers not willing to wait to see of the
last swing high will be retested.  It reflects a sense of urgency to buy.]  The close at the
end of this year says price should make a lower low, at least nominally,
[Compared to
last Qtr low only].  There are times when a low end close can lead to a reversal.  Not
sure that is the case, here.
[Just another possibility of which to be aware.]

The fact that silver cannot get and stay above 35 says how much work there is to
overcome sellers.  2013 should be more of the same, at least for the first half.

SIA Q 30 Dec 12

As with gold, an unusually large bar most often foretells of a protracted trading range to
follow.  Not only did that hold true for silver, the trading range was all under a 50%
retracement area, telling us how rally attempts have been weak, and also a signal from
the market that $50, $100, $250 silver is not on the immediate horizon.

It does not take a crystal ball, nor a Seer to look ahead into 2013 and know, almost
beyond a doubt that silver has its work cut out for the next several months, and one
should be very careful when trading futures, while still buying the physical with impunity.

We did not need to know of any “story” behind either precious metal.  The charts are
all-knowing, and they present everything known about the price, sans any opinion[s].
Just deal with the facts and plan accordingly.  Trust the markets.  They never lie.

SIA M 30 Dec 12


This entry was posted in Market Commentaries. Bookmark the permalink.